‘Between the Ears’: Why Rangers Believe Derek McInnes Can Reset the Title Battle
Not many people in Scottish football know Derek McInnes better than Tony Docherty. The pair worked side by side at St Johnstone and Aberdeen for well over a decade, building a reputation as one of the most resilient coaching partnerships in the country.
Now, as Rangers prepare for a new era under McInnes following Danny Rohl’s departure, Docherty is convinced that the 52-year-old’s competitive streak is precisely what the Ibrox club have been missing in their attempts to sustain a challenge to Celtic over the course of a full campaign.
Mentality at the Heart of Rangers’ Rebuild
The context is stark. When the league split came around last season, Rangers were in second place, one point behind Hearts and ahead of Celtic. Rohl framed the run-in as “five cup finals” – but his side lost four of those matches and slipped to a distant third by the end of the season.
That collapse reinforced long-standing questions over Rangers’ mentality when pressure peaks in the decisive weeks of the Scottish Premiership, the top tier administered by the Scottish Professional Football League. It is that recurring fragility that Docherty believes McInnes, who previously played for Rangers and retains a clear affinity with the club, is best placed to confront.
“Derek is a hugely competitive person,” Docherty says. “You saw that last year, when people thought his team were going to disappear. Purely through him and the recruitment he did they were competitive right the way through.”
For a Rangers squad that has too often struggled to turn opportunity into silverware in recent years, McInnes is being tasked as much with reshaping what happens “between the ears” as with refining tactics or personnel.
Track Record of Pushing Celtic and Defying Expectations
Docherty points to the pattern that McInnes established during his time at Aberdeen, where his sides repeatedly finished behind Brendan Rodgers’ Celtic teams. While Aberdeen fell short of the title, they consistently turned themselves into the nearest challengers, a feat that required both endurance and a refusal to concede ground early in the season.
“It is that mentality, you saw it in abundance last year,” Docherty explains. “You’ve seen it all through his career, the amount of second-place finishes to Brendan Rodgers’ Celtic with an Aberdeen team. And last year, every time Hearts were written off they would come up trumps.”
That reference to Hearts’ resilience underlines why McInnes’ work at Tynecastle has drawn attention beyond Edinburgh. When rivals expected them to fade, they held their nerve deep into the campaign. The implication for Rangers is clear: an Ibrox side with greater financial resources and higher expectations will want that same ability to absorb pressure and respond when the narrative turns against them.
From Rohl to McInnes: A Transition Seen as Opportunity
Former Rangers and Dundee striker Rory Loy views the recent coaching reshuffle as unusually favourable for the Ibrox club. With Rohl leaving and McInnes arriving, Loy believes the sequence of events offers Rangers a cleaner transition than many had anticipated just a few weeks earlier.
“To think three or four weeks ago, some Rangers fans – given the decline after the split – were looking to move him [Rohl] on,” Loy said on the Scottish Football Podcast. “To get money for him and to use that money to recruit Derek McInnes, I don’t think it could have fallen more favourably for Rangers.”
In a league where coaching changes often come amid crisis, the perception that Rangers have managed to turn a period of uncertainty into a strategic reset is significant. It also has competitive consequences: resolving the future of the head coach early gives McInnes maximum time to shape summer recruitment, pre-season conditioning and the psychological messaging that will define the dressing room heading into the new campaign.
The ‘Perfect Scenario’ Built on Mental Strength
For Loy, the key benefit McInnes brings is not merely tactical structure or familiarity with the Scottish game, but a long-proven focus on resilience.
“The one thing Derek McInnes will bring above all else is the one thing that’s been levelled at Rangers for the last decade – that’s what is between the ears, that’s mentality,” he argues.
That view dovetails with Docherty’s belief that McInnes’ experience of Rangers as a player matters. Having already felt the scrutiny that comes with Ibrox from inside the dressing room, McInnes is seen as better positioned to address the emotional volatility that can accompany tight title races and high-stakes derby fixtures.
What It Means for the Title Race
In practical terms, the appointment feeds directly into the dynamics of the Scottish title picture. Celtic have capitalised repeatedly when Rangers have faltered in the spring run-in. Hearts, too, have shown they can capitalise when the Old Firm drop points, turning consistency into leverage in the battle for European qualification.
If McInnes can instil the same edge that sustained Aberdeen as regular runners-up and kept Hearts competitive when written off, Rangers will expect to be better placed to:
- Convert promising league positions at the split into sustained title pressure.
- Respond more forcefully to setbacks in key fixtures.
- Navigate congested schedules without the sharp dips in performance that have previously cost them in the closing weeks.
None of that is guaranteed. But for a club where the conversation has repeatedly circled back to mentality, those closest to McInnes argue that Rangers have at least aligned their biggest perceived weakness with a coach whose career has been built on confronting exactly that issue.
As the new season approaches, the focus at Ibrox will be less on rhetoric and more on whether that competitive edge, so admired by Docherty and Loy, can finally carry Rangers’ title challenge all the way to the final whistle of the campaign.
