Alonso’s Stance on Fernandez Highlights Growing Tension Over Standards at Club Level
The impending exit of Fernandez follows a turbulent period under manager Xabi Alonso, who recently omitted the midfielder from his squad for a Carabao Cup victory against Luton Town. Alonso publicly questioned the mentality and preparation of Fernandez leading up to the fixture.
Explaining the decision to drop him, Alonso stated: “We need the players that are in the best situation to play. We need to take everything into consideration – players that are in a good moment, players that are not feeling that energy to play. For me, it is very important they feel this desire to play and to have good preparation.”
Selection Call That Signals a Broader Shift
Leaving a senior midfielder out of a matchday squad for a domestic cup tie is, on its own, not unusual. Managers regularly rotate for early‑round fixtures, particularly in a competition such as the Carabao Cup, which runs alongside a demanding league calendar and other commitments under the jurisdiction of the English Football League.
What makes this episode significant is not only the omission itself, but Alonso’s choice to address Fernandez’s readiness in public terms. In modern elite dressing rooms, managers often protect players from direct criticism in front of the cameras. By framing his decision around “desire to play” and “good preparation”, Alonso effectively placed professional standards at the centre of the discussion and made selection for the cup tie a litmus test of those standards.
Mentality, Preparation and the Demands of Cup Football
The Carabao Cup, contested by clubs across the top tiers of the English game, compresses fixtures into midweek dates and can quickly add to a side’s workload. For managers, this congestion heightens the importance of players arriving in the “best situation to play” – physically and mentally.
Alonso’s reference to energy and preparation underlines how selection decisions in such competitions extend beyond technical ability. In a knockout format, where a single tie can determine progression, coaches often prioritise:
- Players who have demonstrated full training availability and sharpness in the days preceding the match
- Squad members who clearly embrace the opportunity to play, even when the fixture is not part of the primary league campaign
- Individuals whose mindset aligns with the manager’s tactical and cultural expectations
By explicitly linking his selection to these factors, Alonso framed Fernandez’s omission not as a routine rotation call but as a statement on what will be required to feature in critical fixtures across the season.
Implications for Fernandez and the Dressing-Room Hierarchy
The situation arrives at a delicate moment for Fernandez. An impending departure, combined with a high‑profile omission from a winning cup squad, places his role in the group under scrutiny. Even without public details on negotiations or destinations, being left out after a manager questions mentality inevitably shapes how team‑mates and supporters interpret a player’s status.
For a midfielder, exclusion from a successful cup outing can narrow short‑term opportunities. Cup competitions are often where managers test combinations, reintroduce players returning to form, and reward those pressing for minutes. Missing out on that platform – especially when the team prevails – may accelerate an informal handover of responsibilities to others in the same position group.
Within the dressing room, Alonso’s words also act as a reference point. When a manager publicly defines “desire to play” and “good preparation” as non‑negotiable, players are given a clear benchmark. That can reinforce the authority of those who meet those standards and isolate those whose focus is perceived to be elsewhere, particularly when transfer moves are in the background.
Club Culture and Managerial Authority
At a time when squads are larger, calendars are congested and transfer windows move quickly, such episodes are increasingly about culture as much as tactics. By tying selection to readiness, Alonso strengthened his position that shirt ownership must be earned on a daily basis, not assumed on reputation or contract status.
This approach also aligns with broader trends in elite football management, where coaches are measured not only on results but on how effectively they manage transitions, integrate or move on senior players, and maintain standards across all competitions. A Carabao Cup tie may not define a season, but the decisions made around it can be a clear indicator of where a club is heading and who will be trusted to take it there.
For Fernandez, the next step – whether at his current club or elsewhere – will likely hinge on demonstrating the very qualities his manager highlighted: sustained preparation, visible energy, and an unambiguous desire to compete for a place in the starting XI.